Question: According to the method mentioned in Gita Adhyay 6 Shlok 10 to 15, I meditate by sitting on one seat and bringing the head and other parts into equilibrium. I also keep the fast of Ekadashi. In this way I will attain peace.
Answer: You may please also read Gita Adhyay 6 Shlok 16 in which it is written that oh Arjun, this yog (sadhna) is neither successful of a person who eats excessively, nor of one who does not eat at all (keeps fast). It is neither successful of a person who remains too much awake, nor of one who sleeps a lot, nor is successful of a person who does sadhna by sitting in one place. The method mentioned in Gita Adhyay 6 Shlok 10 to 15 has been refuted in Gita Adhyay 3 Shlok 5 to 9 that a foolish person, who forcefully controlling all the senses of action i.e. by sitting in one place, meditates, he is called a hypocrite. Therefore only a karmyogi (a worshipper who does worship while doing work) is superior. For the real method of bhakti, God (Brahm), the giver of the knowledge of Gita, says about searching some Tatvdarshi (Gita Adhyay 4 Shlok 34). It is evident from this that the method of bhakti told by (Brahm) the giver of the knowledge of Gita is not complete. Therefore in Gita Adhyay 6 Shlok 10 to 15, Brahm (Kshar Purush / Kaal) has described his own way of worship and has described the peace attained from his worship to be very bad (anuttamam ) in Gita Adhyay 7 Shlok 18. It has been said in the above-mentioned Adhyay 6 Shlok 10 to 15 that a worshipper who keeps mind and senses under control, may prepare a special seat which should neither be too high, nor too low. Sitting on that seat, keeping heart and senses under control, must practice by focussing mind. Sitting upright, by observing celibacy, and controlling mind, one must depart. Engrossed in sadhna in this way, a worshipper attains the (Nirvanparmam ) lifeless (nominal) peace residing in me. Therefore in Gita Adhyay 7 Shlok 18, has called the salvation (benefit) attained by his worship to be very inferior (anuttamam ). In this very Gita Adhyay 18 Shlok 62 and Adhyay 15 Shlok 4, he has said that oh Arjun! You will attain supreme peace and Satlok; then one does not have rebirth, attains complete salvation. Even I (God, the giver of the knowledge of Gita) am in the refuge of that Primordial Supreme God . Therefore, one should only do His worship with firm determination.
In Adhyay 6 Shlok 47, he has himself described the path directed on the basis of the conjectural knowledge of his way of worship as (yuktatamH matH) the viewpoints of the darkness of ignorance. The other translators have done the meaning of 'Me yuktatamH matH' to be 'is acceptable as most superior', whereas, they should have done it as - this is my conjectural opinion based on the darkness of ignorance. Because about the true knowledge, he has advised to ask some Tatvdarshi Saint (Gita Adhyay 4 Shlok 34). The actual translation of Gita Adhyay 6 Shlok 47 -
Adhyay 6 Shlok 47
Yoginaam′, api, sarveshaam′, mad gaten, antaraatmna, Shraddhaavaan , bhajte, yaH, maam′, saH, me, yuktatamH, matH ||47||
Translation: The conjectural viewpoint on bhakti which I have given in Shloks 10 to 15, the estimated way of worship which I have mentioned, is not complete knowledge, because (Sarveshaam ) all (yoginaam ) among worshippers (yaH) he who (shraddhaavaan ) with full faith (antaraatmna) with full determination (mad gaten) according to the bhakti-opinion given by me (maam ) me (bhajte) worships (saH) he (api) also (yuktatamH) due to the darkness of ignorance, is engrossed in the worship of birth-death and heaven-hell. (me) my (matH) this is opinion. (47)
Translation: The conjectural viewpoint on bhakti which I have given in Shloks 10 to 15, the estimated way of worship which I have mentioned, is not complete knowledge, because amongst all the worshippers he who worships me with full faith, full determination according to the bhakti-opinion given by me, he, due to the darkness of ignorance, is also engrossed in the worship of birth-death and heaven-hell. This is my opinion.
Its evidence is also clear in Gita Adhyay 7 Shlok 18 and Gita Adhyay 5 Shlok 29 and Gita Adhyay 6 Shlok 15. Therefore, it is said in Gita Adhyay 18 Shlok 62 that Oh Bharat, you may go in the refuge of that Supreme God in every respect. By His grace only, you will attain supreme peace and eternal supreme abode i.e. Satlok. In Gita Adhyay 15 Shlok 4, it is said that when you find the Tatvdarshi Saint mentioned in Gita Adhyay 4 Shlok 34, then you should search for that Supreme State of Supreme God. Having gone where, the worshippers do not return to this world again i.e. they become free from birth and death forever. The Supreme God who has created the world-like tree, I also am in the refuge of that Eternal Supreme God. One should only worship Him.
Even in Gita Adhyay 3 Shlok 5 to 9, he has proved the knowledge of Gita Adhyay 6 Shlok 10 to 15 to be wrong. Arjun asked, "God, it is very difficult to control mind." God answered, "Arjun, controlling mind is like controlling wind." Then, he has also said this that undoubtedly nobody remains without doing any action even for a moment at any time. A very foolish person forcefully controlling all the senses of action externally, keeps thinking something in the mind. Therefore instead of sitting in one place by observing hathyog, it is superior to sadhna (karmyog) while performing worldly tasks. Compared to not doing action i.e. doing sadhna with hath-yog1 by sitting in one place, it is superior to do sadhna while doing actions. How will you subsist yourself by doing sadhna while sitting in one place (Akarmna)? Doing sadhna (by sitting in one seat with hathyog) by abandoning the ordinances of scriptures is a cause of bondage to actions. Secondly, it is superior only to do sadhna while performing actions in accordance with the scriptures. Therefore, do sadhna while performing your worldly tasks. In Gita Adhyay 8 Shlok 7, has said that, fight as well as do my sumiran. In this way, you will come to me only. In Gita Adhyay 7 Shlok 18 and Adhyay 18 Shlok 62, has said that the benefit (salvation) obtained from my sadhna is very inferior/bad (Anuttamam ). Therefore, go in the refuge of that Supreme God, by whose grace you will attain supreme peace and (Shaashvatam Sthanm ) Eternal Place i.e. Satlok. Search for some Tatvdarshi Saint and ask him the method of bhakti and the complete knowledge (Tatvgyan) of that Supreme God; even I (Brahm / Kshar Purush, the giver of the knowledge of Gita) do not know it.
FAQs about Is Peace Attained Through Meditation and Fasting
Q.1 What are the 5 benefits of meditation?
In, Gita Chapter 6 Verse 16 it is being said that, this yog (sadhna) is neither successful of a person who eats excessively, nor of one who does not eat at all (keeps fast). It is neither successful of a person who remains too awake, nor of one who sleeps a lot, nor is it successful of a person who does sadhna by sitting in one place. Thus, one should not meditate.
Q.2 Who is a hypocrite?
A fool is said to be a hypocrite when he forcefully controls all of his senses, such as by sitting still while meditating.
Q. 3 What does Chapter 6 Verse 47 signify?
Gita’s author in Chapter 6 Verse 47 tells that the conjectural viewpoint on bhakti given in Verses 10 to 15 is not complete knowledge, as some worshippers are also engrossed in the worship of birth-death and heaven-hell due to ignorance. This is the author's opinion.
Latest Comments section by users
If you have any query regarding the above content then please email us at [email protected], we will try to solve it with proof.
How to attain a peaceful and happy life on this earth. There are so many problems in life. Kindly advise
This earth is full of misery and sorrow. The only way to attain peace and happiness is to worship Almighty Kabir the creator of the entire universe. Chant true salvation mantras as indicated in Gita Chapter 17:23.
I meditate daily and see divine light. I feel so close to God but am unable to have His audience. What shall I do?
Meditation is not the way to see and attain God. This has been prohibited in pious Gita Ji (6:16). To attain God chant mantras as is mentioned in Gita Chapter 17:23. Take refuge in enlightened Saint. You may visit our website for details.
I keep Ekadashi fast, also every Friday, then during Navratri for 9 days and few others occasionally. Yet I do not have peace in life. Why?
Pious Gita Chapter 6:16, 6:10-15 tells fasting is a useless activity it does not provide peace to seekers. To attain peace and happiness in life you must quit arbitrary practice like Fasting or meditation and worship in accordance to holy scriptures as is evidence in Gita Chapter 17:23.