Spiritual Debate: Sant Rampal Ji vs Dhirendra Shastri


In the Battle of Spirituality,

Hindus are betrayed:

Is Shiva indestructible?

Dhirendra Krishna Shastri is one of the prominent Hindu narrators (Kathavachak) known for his controversial statements and having a large number of followers. In this video, Sant Rampal Ji proves that Shiv is neither eternal nor immortal. Tatvdarshi Sant Rampal ji Maharaj ji has shared insightful evidence that proves Shiv is not an eternal entity. Yes, you read that right. Hold onto your curiosity and don't skip the video because this information is substantiated and not merely a statement in the air.

Dhirendra Shastri's Perception About God Shiva and Vishnu

In one of his spiritual sessions, he expressed his belief in the immortality of Shiva, attributing Shiva as the embodiment of an eternal and Avinashi (indestructible) God. Further, he added that Shiv and Vishnu are not distinct entities but rather one, emphasising the oneness of both.

Sant Rampal Ji Maharaj’s Assertion Shiv and His brothers are Mortal

Sant Rampal Ji asserted that Shiv and his brothers are mortal, and corroborated his statement with compelling evidence. The evidence presented by him is sourced from the "Gita ji,"  published by Gita Press Gorakhpur, which is regarded as an authoritative and authentic reference.

Shiv Ji is in the Cycle of Death and Birth

Diving into the widely held myth that Shiv (Shiva) is beyond the circle of birth and death, Sant Rampal Ji has expressed his grief, stating that by following the false knowledge, none of our ancestors attained salvation, as they have been misguided by fake gurus from thousands of years.

Read the Evidence from Shrimad Bhagwat Purana

And presented the evidence from Shrimad Devi Bhagwat Purana page no 123 3rd Skand, which clarifies that the trinity (Shiv, Brahma, Vishnu)  are mortal which includes the conversation between Devi Durga (wife of Kaal Brahm).

By addressing her mother Shiv is accepting that he and his brothers (Vishnu and Brahma) are in the circle of birth and death and not eternal and also that they are dedicated to working according to the rules only (which clears that they are not master controllers and there is somebody above them).

Citation from Page No 123. clears the Following Points:

1. All three gunas Brahma, Vishnu, and Mahesh are mortal.

2. Durga is the mother of all three of them. (This elucidates that the trinity has a father and mother.)

3.  Brahma is Rajogun  (an attribute which has an innate biological mechanism that drives humans towards reproduction).

Vishnu is Satogun (an attribute that fosters emotional connection and bond with our family and acquaintances). Shiv is Tamogun (an attribute which is related to the emotion of anger).

This also disproves that Vishnu and Shiv are the same, proving Dhirendra Shashtri wrong again. 

4. Trinity is committed to their respective tasks by the rules only. (which insinuates that they are not master- controllers and there is another power above them which has defined their responsibilities.)

5. Durga (The mother of 3 gunas) is also known as "Prakriti ".


The evidence presented here ultimately proves that Dhirendra Shastri's thoughts are baseless. In the end, all the viewers are requested to understand the true spiritual knowledge currently being imparted by Sant Rampal Ji Maharaj Ji. It is the right time because we have a true Saint who is giving true spiritual knowledge. So let us not waste this precious time and break the endless cycle of birth and death and free ourselves from ignorance and fake saints.


FAQs : "Spiritual Debate: Sant Rampal Ji vs Dhirendra Shastri"

Q.1 What is Dhirendra Krishna Shastri's belief about Shiva and Vishnu?

Dhirendra Krishna Shastri believes that Shiva is immortal (indestructible). He also expresses the view that Shiva and Vishnu are not distinct entities but are one, emphasizing their oneness and eternal nature.

Q.2 How does Sant Rampal Ji Maharaj counter Dhirendra Shastri's belief about Shiva?

Sant Rampal Ji Maharaj asserts that Shiva and his brothers, Vishnu and Brahma, are mortal. He presents evidence from the Shrimad Devi Bhagwat Puran and the Gita to support his claim that they are subject to the cycle of birth and death and are not eternal.

Q. 3 What evidence does Sant Rampal Ji Maharaj provide to prove that Shiva is not immortal?

Sant Rampal Ji Maharaj cites the Shrimad Devi Bhagwat Purana (page 123, 3rd Skand) where it is mentioned that Shiva, Vishnu, and Brahma are mortal and in the cycle of birth and death. He also refers to the Gita published by Gita Press Gorakhpur to substantiate this claims.

Q.4 According to Sant Rampal Ji, who is the mother of Shiva, Vishnu, and Brahma?

According to Sant Rampal Ji, Durga is the mother of Shiva, Vishnu, and Brahma. This is based on the evidence from the Shrimad Devi Bhagwat Purana, which indicates that the trinity has both a father and a mother.

Q.5 How does Sant Rampal Ji explain the attributes of Brahma, Vishnu, and Shiva?

Sant Rampal Ji explains by citing scriptures that Brahma embodies Rajogun (an attribute related to reproduction), Vishnu represents Satogun (an attribute fostering emotional connections and bonds), and Shiva signifies Tamogun (an attribute related to anger). These attributes suggest that they are distinct and not the same.

Q.6 What does Sant Rampal Ji say about the master controllers of the universe?

Sant Rampal Ji proves from scriptures that Shiva, Vishnu, and Brahma are not the master controllers of the universe. They are bound by rules and responsibilities defined by a higher power, indicating that there is an entity above them who controls everything.

Q.7 How does Sant Rampal Ji's interpretation challenge the widely held belief about Shiva's immortality?

By presenting scriptural evidence that Shiva and his brothers are mortal and part of the cycle of birth and death, Sant Rampal Ji challenges the widely held belief in Shiva's immortality. He asserts that this belief has misled people for generations and prevented them from attaining true salvation.


Recent Comments

Latest Comments by users
If you have any query regarding the above content then please email us at [email protected], we will try to solve it with proof.
Satish Tiwari

Dhirendra Shastri is a very famous Guru right now, and his words are believed to come true. He is also promoting Sanatan Dharm by chanting Sita-Ram. As Hindus, we request that no misinformation be spread about him because he is promoting Santan Dharma.

Satlok Ashram

Dear reader, we appreciate your perspective on our article. It's true that Dhirendra Shastri has gained fame for his claims that his words come true. However, these are not the sole characteristics of a complete Guru. A true Guru has many qualities that help devotees achieve everything they need through the true way of worship. One does not need to bow before anyone for help; only the Almighty can assist through true worship. Sanatan Dharm is based on the Vedas, not by chanting Sita-Ram. There is no scriptural evidence that chanting Sita-Ram provides any benefits to devotees. Currently, Sant Rampal Ji Maharaj is the one promoting Sanatan Dharm by offering the true way of worship in line with our scriptures and sharing true knowledge from them. We urge you not to be easily swayed by any gurus based on their dramatic words or fame. Instead, analyze what is true from our Holy scriptures and understand the characteristics of a complete Saint. For more information, we recommend reading the book "Gyan Ganga" and listening to the spiritual discourses of Sant Rampal Ji Maharaj.

Anant Gupta

It’s distressing that India is being misled by gurus who lack proper education and deceive the population. It’s particularly sad that educated individuals are falling for such people, whose primary goal is to run businesses. This is why I don’t respect any current gurus, as they are all misleading society.

Satlok Ashram

Dear reader, we value your opinion on our article. It's true that many gurus are merely running businesses in the name of God, which is a grave sin. Gurus like Dhirendra Shastri, who lack knowledge of our scriptures, become famous due to their past good karma and attractive words. Educated people, without understanding what is written in our scriptures and the true characteristics of a Guru, are often attracted to such gurus because of their appealing words and large followings. However, not all gurus are the same. At any given time, there exists a complete Guru on earth who possesses true spiritual knowledge from our scriptures and provides the correct way to worship the Almighty God, benefiting devotees. After gaining complete spiritual knowledge from our scriptures, people are less likely to be misled by such gurus. Sant Rampal Ji Maharaj is exposing these fake gurus who mislead society, as you can see in his discourses available on various social media platforms and in the book "Gyan Ganga."